-
Senior Member
registered user
Totally different approaches, for different purposes IMHO
This approach and Werner's are almost diametrically opposite approaches to remastering, and suitable for very different purposes. And if "remastering" means creating a new ISO image for CD/DVD, this is of course not remastering at all.
But, in my understanding, remastering means essentially recompressing a modified UNIONFS, possibly together with other modifications. That's what I and a few other users need, and provided the necessary boot files are present, copy/backup by the built-in Install Knoppix to flash disk can be used.
As for virtual machines, I have found qemu very useful for checking the remastering, but personally, I don't really need them when I don't modify minirt.gz. Nor have I ever needed a hard disk install for remastering. That was necessary to build a pure 64 bits Knoppix version in a straightforward way, but that's a different story.
-
But, in my understanding, remastering means essentially recompressing a
modified UNIONFS, possibly
together with other modifications.
You'll get all of this while using a remastered CD by my way with "Install KNOPPIX to flash disk"
The other method is "recombine"; but I don't like it and I tested it not very well. Modifing Knoppix in a real HD-installation is more versatile.
Greetings Werner * http://www.wp-schulz.de/knoppix/summary.html
Own Rescue-CD (Knoppix V6.7.1 remaster)
-
Senior Member
registered user
Originally Posted by
Werner P. Schulz
You'll get all of this while using a remastered CD by my way with "Install KNOPPIX to flash disk"
The other method is "
recombine"; but I don't like it and I tested it not very well. Modifing Knoppix in a real HD-installation is more versatile.
Greetings Werner *
http://www.wp-schulz.de/knoppix/summary.html
Own Rescue-CD (Knoppix V6.7.1 remaster)
That just points back to entirely different use situations. For my needs, I have yet to discover one single way modifying Knoppix in real HD install is more versatile than using Poor Man's Install (PMI) - my experience is rather to the contrary, which is also why I hesitate to create a 64-bits 6.7.1-version - I'll rather wait for the next release, to see if a pure 64-bits version can be made more easily from a PMI then.. I can't speak for you, and you clearly don't speak for me.
My major Knoppix use is not for testing, experimenting or rescue purposes, but as a workstation OS. Since 6.0, Knoppix has been the main OS version in my daily work. Therefore, CD versions are of little or no interest to me, and I don't really have to comply with the 4 GB limits either - I just find it practical to do that for now.
Normally I use at least 16 GB USB sticks, and I can hardly see any way syslinux/isolinux serves me better than legacy GRUB on those devices - on the contrary, I usually set up 3-4 partitions, and tailor different boot options for different Knoppix packages on the partitions. Which is very handy with legacy GRUB, and at the very least, I don't have to learn another booting tool well.
-
I may not be bit clear here, but does remastering mean considerable removal of installed application and install of new/other application, or just addition of few new applications onto existing knoppix system?
Knoppix does provide means to extend the existing system by adding additional cloop files in /KNOPPIX dir. I have used this method effectively (several updates) over existing 6.7.1 and in previous versions.
Some benefits of this method (only in case of USB installs):
1. Any new cloop file, example, compilation of forensic/networking applications can be shared separately, removing the hassle to download full DVD.
2. Even if a minor update is performed it can be added as cloop (though it would take more disk space), eg LibreOffice update.
The idea here is to build a set of downloadable/shareable cloop files, thus making Knoppix easy to update.
Example:
1. Cloop file for 6.7 to 6.7.1
2. Cloop extra networking tools for 6.7+ and so on...
Later, if needed it would not be very difficult for users to make a DVD version.
Last edited by vkrishn; 01-06-2012 at 10:20 AM.
Reason: Typo
-
Senior Member
registered user
May be a very useful idea
Yes, with the present DVD image size, in order to stick to the 4GB limit for cloop KNOPPIX, we have to remove programs to make room for substantial additions. (In my case, R, VMware Workstation and Oracle XE are the most important ones.) Instead of doing this, which is getting harder and harder to achieve while still keeping functionality intact, using the ability to chain cloop files can be very useful. I think that the main reason it has not been exploited more, is that it is kind of "third level" extension: First, the persistent store caters for most needs, second, creating a new primary cloop image suffices for most of the rest. I'm rather doubtful as to the usefulness of implementing version upgrades this way. Even within one release, it quickly becomes an hassle to keep it upgraded, and I guess this will be even worse across versions.
-
Originally Posted by
Capricorny
Yes, with the present DVD image size, in order to stick to the 4GB limit for cloop KNOPPIX, we have to remove programs to make room for substantial additions. (In my case, R, VMware Workstation and Oracle XE are the most important ones.) Instead of doing this, which is getting harder and harder to achieve while still keeping functionality intact, using the ability to chain cloop files can be very useful. I think that the main reason it has not been exploited more, is that it is kind of "third level" extension: First, the persistent store caters for most needs, second, creating a new primary cloop image suffices for most of the rest. I'm rather doubtful as to the usefulness of implementing version upgrades this way. Even within one release, it quickly becomes an hassle to keep it upgraded, and I guess this will be even worse across versions.
I would not refute that DVD 4GB limit is the core essense here, but
1. How many users/percentage who have downloaded, say 6.7 and regularly use it from DVD? Or is DVD version become more a storage/distribution media?
2. What percentage of users would want to have distributable version of cloop file for VMware Workstation and Oracle XE (I mean if it free from license hassles)? I would!!
3. Would I be downloading updatedable cloop for 6.7 even if its 1GB in size, rather than 4 GB DVD?
If one uses Knoppix on several systems (USB), he would likely use an update method.
I am more keen on various addon cloop modules that can be build apart from regular DVD.
-
Senior Member
registered user
My current two cents worth:
.
I use a 2 Gb Knoppix 6.7.1 LiveUSB as my mainstay OS.
I am not a programmer, but a frequent user.
My uses include internet browsing, e-mail and maintenance of some
personally useful spreadsheets with on-line information.
The CD size of Knoppix with its overlay process suits me very well,
with one exception: that is, when it comes to upgrading some its
larger elements like LibreOfffice or IceWeasel. Re-mastering is the
only really effective way I see to maintain a small end-product. However,
for my particular end uses, re-mastering requires too much additional
resource outlay, and frankly, getting it done exceeds
my short attention span.
I've tried several virtual system aproaches, and am not really
comfortable with any I've tried.
I expect I might be able to pull together an 'in situ' menu-item re-
mastering from available on-line material, but it would require most
of a 16 Gb usb. That would seem to be an absurdly wasteful
use of resources IMO.
Some other distros are going to minimalist base distributions as one
way of getting around my sort of problem. More frequent Knoppix upgrades
would also suffice, but KK has a day job and a family. I suppose he
might delegate some of his distro maintenance tasks if someone
competent were to propose something appropriate.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
ProLabs 10GBase-TX SFP+ RJ-45 Copper Transceiver Module P/N: SFP-10GBASE-T-C NEW
$34.99
NEW Sealed Cisco SFP-10G-LR 10GBASE-LR SFP+ 1310nm 10km *US Shipping*
$18.00
New HP Aruba J9150D 10GBASE-SR SFP+ Transceiver Module
$35.88
New Cisco w/ Green Hologram SFP-25G-SR-S 25G SFP28 SR 850nm 300m LC MMF Module
$69.99
Genuine Cisco SFP-10G-SR V03 10GBASE-SR SFP+ Transceiver Module 10-2415-03
$8.00
Brand New Cisco GLC-LH-SMD 1000BASE-LX/LH SFP Module 1310nm 10km SMF LC
$10.99
Cisco SFP-10G-SR SFP+ MMF 10GBase-SR 850nm Transceiver Module 1 Year Warranty
$28.49
Lot of 10 - HP 10Gb SR SFP+ Transceiver 455883-B21 455885-001 456096-001 850nm
$25.99
Lot 10: Genuine Cisco SFP-10G-SR-S 10GBase-SR SFP+ Module Transceiver 10-3105-01
$149.00
GENUINE CISCO DS-SFP-FC32G-SW SFP NEW SEALED SEE PHOTOS SHIPS FREE
$69.99